In March 2022, true crime podcast host Jane MacSorley recorded an interview with a man who the police say is Nicholas Rossi, an American fugitive suspected of faking his own death.
Recently discharged from a Covid ward in Glasgow, the alleged fugitive is in a wheelchair and is struggling to breathe through an oxygen mask. He tells Jane that he is a victim of mistaken identity. He says he is an innocent Irishman called Arthur Knight. His English wife Miranda assures Jane that Arthur has never even been to the United States. The story makes headlines globally.
After her first meeting with Arthur and Miranda, Jane believes the police have made a mistake. She embarks on a yearlong investigation, making a unique discovery which changes everything.